“Wittman v. Personhuballah – A Standing-Only Recap”
Smart thoughts from Asher Steinberg.
Category Archives: redistricting
“Election Law’s Path in the Roberts Court’s First Decade: A Sharp Right Turn but with Speed Bumps and Surprising Twists”
I have posted a revised version of this paper (forthcoming, Stanford Law Review) to take into account the death of Justice Scalia. Here is the revised abstract:
This Essay describes the path of election law jurisprudence in the Roberts Court… Continue reading
More on the #SCOTUS Oral Argument in Virginia Congressional Redistricting Case
I have now had a chance to review the transcript in Wittman v. Personhuballah, and I agree with other commentators that it seems very likely that the Republican intervenors is likely to fail. It appears that the four Court… Continue reading
Supreme Court Likely to Affirm Racial Gerrymandering Finding in VA Redistricting Case
WaPo:
The Supreme Court on Monday seemed likely to leave in place a lower court’s decision that Virginia improperly considered race when drawing congressional districts.
Operating without the late Justice Antonin Scalia, it would require only four members of the… Continue reading
“BREAKING: Federal Court Rules Prison Gerrymandering Unconstitutional”
Alice Ollstein:
The Federal District Court for Florida’s Northern District ruled Monday that the prison gerrymandering in Florida’s Jefferson County unconstitutionally dilutes the voting power of its residents. By packing inmates who can’t vote into a district, but counting… Continue reading
“Wittman v. Personhuballah, The Term’s Standing-Law Sleeper”
Asher Steinberg:
In sum, Personhuballah has the potential to remake standing in election law, moving candidates and their lost chances of electoral success to the forefront of districting litigation where they’ve always belonged. But Personhuballah also has the potential… Continue reading
“Va. Republicans take redistricting fight to the Supreme Court”
Bob Barnes and Jenna Portnoy for WaPo:
The Supreme Court will take another shot at that in the Virginia case. A panel of federal judges said the commonwealth’s plan veered from partisan gerrymandering aimed at protecting incumbents — for which… Continue reading
Lyle Denniston Previews Va Racial Gerrymandering Case, Argued Next Week at #SCOTUS
“North Carolina Exemplifies National Battles Over Voting Laws”
Must-read NYT Richard Fausset:
The purest distillation of the nation’s wars over voting rules and legislative gerrymandering is playing out in North Carolina.
A high-profile lawsuit is taking on a voter identification law and other voting changes. There are four… Continue reading
“In Md. and Va., efforts to end gerrymandering face major obstacles: Lawmakers”
“The best laid plans; Court ruling once again splits North Carolina primaries”
That’s the lead story in this week’s Electionline Weekly.
Plaintiffs In NC Redistricting Case Make Forceful Argument State’s Remedial Plan is Unconstitutional Partisan Gerrymander
While much of the brief is about how the NC legislature’s new plan is no cure for the earlier redistricting plan found to be a racial gerrymander, perhaps what is most interesting is the discussion of how open and blatant… Continue reading
“Judge revises proposed court schedule in NC redistricting case”
The latest from NC.
“The Role of Partisan Advantage in North Carolina’s Redistricting Map”
Michael Parsons:
In North Carolina, the legislature is attempting to justify a map with a 10-3 split, which does not reasonably reflect statewide voter preference, based on an alleged state interest in political advantage. For reasons I discuss at… Continue reading