Category Archives: redistricting
No, The Evenwel Case Does Not Put the Apportionment of Congressional Districts to the States in Play
Richard Winger helpfully points out some confusion about the effects of Evenwel on reapportionment. So let’s make this clear.
1. At issue in Evenwel, is whether drawing district for state legislatures and other state purposes must be done on total… Continue reading
Chief Justice, While Government Lawyer, Defended One Person, One Vote Total Population Rule
Great find by Marty Lederman, who praises the Chief’s analysis.
Watch these arguments, and perhaps even this brief, be cited in the Evenwel briefing.
“One Person One Vote Goes to the Supreme Court”
Great interview with Nate Persily by Madeiline Brand.
“‘One Man, One Vote’ Keeps Changing”
Noah Feldman for Bloomberg View.
Why the Court Should Leave the Choice of One Person One Vote Rules to the States
In my Slate piece on the Supreme Court’s decision to hear Evenwel, which I wanted to title “Unsettling Precedents,” I argue that whether to use total population or total voters (or perhaps some other denominator) in redistricting to comply with… Continue reading
“Supreme Court to consider redefining ‘one-person, one-vote’ principle”
Richard Wolf reports for USA Today.
“Of People, Trees, Acres, Dollars, and Voters”
Joey Fishkin:
And so the question before the Court now is this: does a poor, urban, Latino kid, not yet 18, deserve to be able to say “this representative represents me. Not acres, trees, dollars, active voters, and so… Continue reading
“5 Points On How ‘One Person, One Vote’ Is Suddenly In Jeopardy”
Tierney Sneed for TPM.
Divided 4th Circuit Panel Revives Redistricting Suit in Wake County, NC School Board Elections
Very interesting opinion and dissent, relying on a Larios-type claim for rejecting deviations from one person, one vote principles.
Quote of the Day: Evenwel Edition
“We don’t have a national list of citizens,” he said. The data cited in the Texas case come from a census survey of about 2% of households that counts citizens.
“If you are only counting 2% of the households, there… Continue reading
“Supreme Court could deal California ‘a one-two punch’ on redistricting”
“U.S. Supreme Court to decide whether ‘one person, one vote’ includes non-citizens”
David Savage reports for the LA Times.
See also Melanie Mason’s, “Could U.S. Supreme Court Shrink California’s Congressional Clout?”
“Supreme Court to hear challenge to Texas redistricting plan”
Bob Barnes reports for WaPo.