Category Archives: Supreme Court
“How Much Speech Did You Take in Last Month?”
Marcia Coyle on Souter’s Draft Dissent in Citizens United
Earlier today I linked to Adam Liptak’s interview with Justice Stevens about campaign finance and his proposed amendment.
A reader reminded me that Marcia Coyle’s excellent 2013 book, The Roberts Court: the Struggle for the Constitution, provides an… Continue reading
“State Aggregate Limits and Proportional Bans under McCutcheon”
New report from CCP. “Policymakers in the District of Columbia and the 18 states with aggregate limits and proportional bans should strongly consider repealing these speech-stifling regulations in order to comply with the precedent set in the McCutcheon decision and… Continue reading
“The Roberts Court on Free Speech, & Snapshots of 2013-2014 Term”
Justice Stevens Especially Unconvincing About His Partisan Gerrymandering Amendment
In my Daily Beast review of Justice Stevens new book, Six Amendments, I was pretty tough on Justice Stevens. I focused on campaign finance, but there are problems throughout the book on questions of drafting of the amendments and… Continue reading
More on Justice Breyer’s Citation to Book Not in the Record
The other day I noted that Justice Breyer cited to unavailable scholarship in his McCutcheon dissent. I updated the post to reflect that Derek Muller had made those points when the opinion was released, something I had missed. Here’s another… Continue reading
Today’s Must-Read: Liptak Talks to Justice Stevens About Citizens United, McCutcheon
For one thing, in this column Justice Stevens confirms the rumors swirling for years that Justice Souter wrote the first draft of a Citizens United dissent. (I called for its release in this Slate column.)
The draft dissent,… Continue reading
Watch Justice Stevens’ ABC interview About “Six Amendments”
Election Law Cartoon of the Day
Here.
“Money Won’t Buy You Votes”
Peter Schuck has written this oped for the LA Times.
“Change the Constitution in Six Easy Steps? It Won’t Be That Simple, Justice Stevens; From campaign finance to political gerrymandering, the retired Supreme Court justice skips hard arguments in his new book in favor of unrealistic, poorly drafted solutions. “
I have written this book review for The Daily Beast. It begins:
Reading retired Supreme Court Justice John Paul Stevens’s new book, Six Amendments: How and Why We Should Change the Constitution, I was reminded of an old Steve… Continue reading
“Ifill: Supreme Court’s campaign finance ruling cheapens voting”
Sherrilyn Ifill oped on McCutcheon.
Perhaps for First Time, Justice Breyer’s McCutcheon Dissent Cites Unavailable Forthcoming Scholarship
I was rereading McCutcheon last night in preparation for a Monday talk on the case at the Center for the Study of Democracy. I noticed that Justice Breyer cites to Robert Post’s forthcoming book on Citizens United:
That is… Continue reading