Election Law Blog
Rick Hasen's blog
Skip to content
Election Law Blog
← “GOP lawyers’ group chief: ‘Desperate’ Holder distorted our study to fit anti-voter ID agenda”
Same as It Ever Was Dept. →

“Court created a civic monster with Citizens United”

Posted on April 14, 2012 1:35 pm by Rick Hasen

Nick Gier oped.

Share
This entry was posted in campaign finance. Bookmark the permalink.
← “GOP lawyers’ group chief: ‘Desperate’ Holder distorted our study to fit anti-voter ID agenda”
Same as It Ever Was Dept. →

Comments are closed.

  • Have a Comment?

    E-Mail Me at rhasen-AT-law.uci.edu

    Election Law Blogger
    Rick Hasen (posts)

    Guest Bloggers
    Heather Gerken (posts)
    Justin Levitt (posts)
    Nate Persily (posts)
    Rick Pildes (posts)
    Dan Tokaji (posts)
  • Generously Supported By


    UCI School of Law
  • ELB Feeds and Email Subscriptions


    Follow rickhasen on Twitter

    Follow Election Law Blog on FaceBook

    RSS Feed RSS XML

    Get ELB Delivered by E-Mail to Your In-box via Feedburner

  • Books by Rick


    The Voting Wars: From Florida 2000 to the Next Election Meltdown (Yale University Press, 2012)
    thevotingwars.gif

    The Voting Wars Website

    NOW AVAILABLE from
    Amazon
    Barnes and Noble


    Remedies: Examples & Explanations by Richard L. Hasen

    Remedies: Examples & Explanations (Aspen Publishers, 3d ed. 2012)


    electionlaw.gif

    Election Law--Cases and Materials (5th edition 2012) (with Daniel Hays Lowenstein and Daniel P. Tokaji)
    supremecourt.gif

    The Supreme Court and Election Law: Judging Equality from Baker v. Carr to Bush v. Gore (NYU Press 2003)
    Book introduction
    Table of Contents
    Order from Amazon.com
    Order from BarnesandNoble.com
    Journal of Legislation Symposium on book


    ggtorts.gif

    The Glannon Guide to Torts: Learning Torts Through Multiple-Choice Questions and Analysis (Aspen Publishers 2d ed. 2011)


  • Election Law Resources


    Election Law--Cases and Materials (5th edition 2012 (with Daniel Hays Lowenstein and Daniel P. Tokaji)
    2013 SUPPLEMENT COMING LATE JULY 2013
    Election Law Journal
    Election Law Listserv homepage
    Election Law Teacher Database
    Repository of Election Law Teaching Materials (2011 update)

  • Blogroll/Political News Sites


    All About Redistricting (Justin Levitt)
    American Constitution Society
    Balkinization
    Ballot Access News
    Brennan Center for Justice
    The Brookings Institution's Campaign Finance Page
    Buzzfeed Politics
    California Election Law (Randy Riddle)
    Caltech-MIT/Voting Technology Project (and link to voting technology listserv)
    The Caucus (NY Times)
    Campaign Legal Center (Blog)
    Campaign Finance Institute
    Center for Competitive Politics (Blog)
    Center for Governmental Studies
    Doug Chapin (HHH program)
    Concurring Opinions
    CQ Politics
    Demos
    Election Updates
    Excess of Democracy (Derek Muller)
    Fairvote
    Election Law@Moritz
    Electionline.org
    Equal Vote (Dan Tokaji)
    Federal Election Commission
    The Fix (WaPo)
    The Hill

    How Appealing
    Initiative and Referendum Institute
    Legal Theory (Larry Solum)
    Mischiefs of Faction
    The Monkey Cage
    More Soft Money Hard Law (Bob Bauer
    Political Activity Law
    Political Wire
    Politico
    Prawfsblawg
    Roll Call
    Slate Politics
    SCOTUSblog
    Summary Judgments (Loyola Law faculty blog)
    Talking Points Memo
    UC Irvine Center for the Study of Democracy
    UC Irvine School of Law
    USC-Caltech Center for the Study of Law and Politics
    The Volokh Conspiracy
    Votelaw blog (Ed Still)
    Washington Post Politics
    Why Tuesday?

  • Recent Commentaries and Op-Eds


    The Supreme Court Gives States New Weapons in the Voting Wars, Daily Beast, June 17, 2013

    It's About the Disclosure, Stupid: The larger failing behind the terrible IRS treatment of Tea Party groups, Slate, May 14, 2013

    Same-Sex Marriage: Court on the Couch, Reuters Opinion, Mar. 26, 2013

    The Voting Wars Within: Is the Justice Department Too Biased to Enforce the Voting Rights Act?, Slate, Mar. 18, 2013

    Who Controls Voting Rights?, Reuters Opinion, Feb. 26, 2013

    After Scalia: Don’t Give Up on Campaign Finance Reform, However Hopeless It Seems Now, Slate, Feb. 21, 2013

    If the Court Strikes Down Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act, Reuters Opinion, Jan. 30, 2013

    Democrats, Don’t Freak Out! Why Fear that Republicans Will Gerrymander the Electoral College are Overblown, Slate, Jan. 25, 2013

    Big Money Lost, But Don't Be Relieved, CNN Opinion, Nov. 9, 2012

    A Better Way to Vote: Nationalize Oversight and Control, NY Times, "Room for Debate" blog, Nov. 9, 2012

    Election Day Dispatches Entry 5: Black Panthers, Navy Seals, and Mysterious Voting Machines, Slate, Nov. 6, 2012

    Behind the Voting Wars, A Clash of Philosophies, Sacramento Bee, Nov. 4, 2012

    How Many More Near-Election Disasters Before Congress Wakes Up?, The Daily Beast, Oct. 30, 2012

    Will Bush v. Gore Save Barack Obama? If Obama Narrowly Wins Ohio, He Can Thank Scalia and the Court's Conservatives, Slate, Oct. 26, 2012

    Will Voter Suppression and Dirty Tricks Swing the Election?, Salon, Oct. 22, 2012

    Is the Supreme Court About to Swing Another Presidential Election? If the Court Cuts Early Voting in Ohio, It Could Be a Difference Maker in the Buckeye State, Slate, Oct. 15, 2012

    Election Truthers: Will Republicans Accept an Obama Election Victory?, Slate, Oct. 9, 2012

    Wrong Number: The Crucial Ohio Voting Battle You Haven't Heard About, Slate, Oct. 1, 2012

    Litigating the Vote, National Law Journal, Aug. 27, 2012

    Military Voters as Political Pawns, San Diego Union-Tribune, August 19, 2012

    Tweeting the Next Election Meltdown: If the Next Presidential Election Goes into Overtime, Heaven Help Us. It’s Gonna Get Ugly, Slate, Aug. 14, 2012

    A Detente Before the Election, New York Times, August 5, 2012

    Worse Than Watergate: The New Campaign Finance Order Puts the Corruption of the 1970s to Shame, Slate, July 19, 2012

    Has SCOTUS OK'd Campaign Dirty Tricks?, Politico, July 10, 2012

    End the Voting Wars: Take our elections out of the hands of the partisan and the incompetent, Slate, June 13, 2012

    Citizens: Speech, No Consequences, Politico, May 31, 2012

    Is Campaign Disclosure Heading Back to the Supreme Court? Don’t expect to see Karl Rove’s Rolodex just yet, Slate, May 16, 2012

    Unleash the Hounds Why Justice Souter should publish his secret dissent in Citizens United, Slate, May 16, 2012

    Why Washington Can’t Be Fixed; And is about to get a lot worse, Slate, May 9, 2012

    Let John Edwards Go! Edwards may be a liar and a philanderer, but his conviction will do more harm than good, Slate, April 23, 2012

    The Real Loser of the Scott Walker Recall? The State of Wisconsin, The New Republic, April 13, 2012

    A Court of Radicals: If the justices strike down Obamacare, it may have grave political implications for the court itself, Slate, March 30, 2012

    Of Super PACs and Corruption, Politico, March 22, 2012

    Texas Voter ID Law May Be Headed to the Supreme Court, Fort Worth Star-Telegram, Mar. 13, 2012

    “The Numbers Don’t Lie: If you aren’t sure Citizens United gave rise to the Super PACs, just follow the money, Slate, Mar. 9, 2012

    Stephen Colbert: Presidential Kingmaker?, Politico, Mar. 5 2012

    Occupy the Super PACs; Justice Ginsburg knows the Citizens United decision was a mistake. Now she appears to be ready to speak truth to power, Slate, Feb. 20, 2012

    Kill the Caucuses! Maine, Nevada, and Iowa were embarrassing. It’s time to make primaries the rule, Slate, Feb. 15, 2012

    The Biggest Danger of Super PACs, CNN Politics, Jan. 9, 2012

    This Case is a Trojan Horse, New York Times "Room for Debate" blog, Jan. 6, 2012 (forum on Bluman v. FEC)



    Read more opeds from 2006-2009, and these from 2010-2011.

  • Forthcoming Publications, Recent Articles, and Working Papers


    Political Dysfunction and Constitutional Change, 86 Drake Law Review (forthcoming 2013) (symposium) (draft available)

    Is “Dependence Corruption” Distinct from a Political Equality Argument for Campaign Finance Reform? A Reply to Professor Lessig, 12 Election Law Journal (forthcoming 2013)

    The 2012 Voting Wars, Judicial Backstops, and the Resurrection of Bush v. Gore, George Washington Law Review (forthcoming 2013) (draft available)

    A Constitutional Right to Lie in Campaigns and Elections?, 74 Montana Law Review 53 (2013)

    End of the Dialogue? Political Polarization, the Supreme Court, and Congress, 86 Southern California Law Review 205 (2013)

    Fixing Washington, 126 Harvard Law Review 550 (2012)

    What to Expect When You’re Electing: Federal Courts and the Political Thicket in 2012, Federal Lawyer, (2012)

    Chill Out: A Qualified Defense of Campaign Finance Disclosure Laws in the Internet Age, 27 Journal of Law and Politics 557 (2012)

    Lobbying, Rent Seeking, and the Constitution, 64 Stanford Law Review 191 (2012)

    Anticipatory Overrulings, Invitations, Time Bombs, and Inadvertence: How Supreme Court Justices Move the Law, 61 Emory Law Journal 779 (2012)

    Teaching Bush v. Gore as History, 56 St. Louis University Law Review 665 (2012) (symposium on teaching election law)

    The Supreme Court’s Shrinking Election Law Docket: A Legacy of Bush v. Gore or Fear of the Roberts Court?, 10 Election Law Journal 325 (2011)

    Citizens United and the Orphaned Antidistortion Rationale, 27 Georgia State Law Review 989 (2011) (symposium on Citizens United)

    The Nine Lives of Buckley v. Valeo, in First Amendment Stories, Richard Garnett and Andrew Koppelman, eds., Foundation 2011)

    The Transformation of the Campaign Financing Regime for U.S. Presidential Elections, in The Funding of Political Parties (Keith Ewing, Jacob Rowbottom, and Joo-Cheong Tham, eds., Routledge 2011)

    Judges as Political Regulators: Evidence and Options for Institutional Change, in Race, Reform and Regulation of the Electoral Process, (Gerken, Charles, and Kang eds., Cambridge 2011)

    Citizens United and the Illusion of Coherence, 109 Michigan Law Review 581 (2011)

    Articles 2004-2007
    Articles 2007-2010

  • About Rick Hasen


    Rick Hasen's home page at UC Irvine School of Law

    Contact Rick by e-mail

    2005 Profile of Rick in the Los Angeles Daily Journal

    2002 Profile of Rick in the Los Angeles Daily Journal

    Crescat Sententia's 20 Question interview with me

  • Disclosure: My role in some litigation/election issues


    I am consulting in Nevada Ethics Commission v. Carrigan

    I am one of the lawyers for the City of San Diego in the Thalheimer campaign contributions challenge

    The pro bono brief I've filed in the Crawford (Indiana voter identification case) in the Supreme Court

    The pro bono amicus brief of Richard Briffault and Rick Hasen in the Wisconsin Right to Life case in the Supreme Court

    My pro bono amicus letter in 9th Circuit supporting defendants' request for rehearing in Padilla v. Lever

    I am consulting for the California Nurses Association on their campaign finance initiative (Proposition 89) (see also Yes on 89)

    I do some consulting work with Horvitz & Levy, LLP

    My pro bono amicus letter in 9th Circuit supporting plaintiffs in Monterey initiative case

    My motion to file amicus brief/amicus brief supporting appellants in the ACLU punch card recall case

    United States Supreme Court amicus brief that I wrote for the Center for Governmental Studies in the BCRA case

  • Archives

  • Categories

    • absentee ballots (110)
    • alternative voting systems (66)
    • ballot access (185)
    • bribery (45)
    • Bush v. Gore reflections (41)
    • campaign finance (3789)
    • campaigns (625)
    • chicanery (505)
    • citizen commissions (118)
    • conflict of interest laws (173)
    • cumulative voting (3)
    • Department of Justice (282)
    • direct democracy (70)
    • election administration (2398)
    • Election Assistance Commission (29)
    • election law "humor" (62)
    • election law and constitutional law (2)
    • election law biz (84)
    • Elections Clause (41)
    • electoral college (120)
    • ethics investigations (97)
    • federal election commission (69)
    • felon voting (35)
    • Fixing Election Administration (10)
    • fraudulent fraud squad (180)
    • guest blogging election law scholarship (6)
    • internet voting (28)
    • John Edwards (82)
    • judicial elections (158)
    • legislation and legislatures (474)
    • lobbying (278)
    • military voting (59)
    • NVRA (motor voter) (48)
    • pedagogy (36)
    • petition clause (4)
    • petition signature gathering (22)
    • political equality (2)
    • political parties (297)
    • political polarization (146)
    • primaries (173)
    • provisional ballots (85)
    • recall elections (160)
    • recounts (46)
    • redistricting (742)
    • referendum (30)
    • Remedies (15)
    • residency (48)
    • social media and social protests (40)
    • SOS White (44)
    • Speech or Debate Clause (8)
    • statutory interpretation (48)
    • Supreme Court (704)
    • tax law and election law (495)
    • term limits (5)
    • The Voting Wars (1907)
    • theory (14)
    • third parties (148)
    • Torts (4)
    • Uncategorized (18914)
    • vote buying (18)
    • voter id (786)
    • voter initiatives (3)
    • voter registration (276)
    • voting (301)
    • Voting Rights Act (1027)
    • voting technology (103)
    • vra renewal guest blogging (108)
  • SiteMeter

© 2013 - Election Law Blog
Proudly powered by WordPress. Weaver by WPWeaver.info