Category Archives: ballot access

“Why Americans Elect Crashed And Burned”

TPM reports.

Share
Posted in ballot access, third parties | Comments Off

“699 Comments ‘Birther’ controversy: Arizona election official says it’s ‘possible’ Obama might not make ballot “

Unbelievable.

Share
Posted in ballot access | Comments Off

“‘Americans Elect’ Ends Online Primary After No Candidates Qualify To Run”

ABC News reportsWaPo has the group’s statement, which at least some opponents of AE thinks leaves wiggle room for something.  After all, as Ken Vogel noted on Twitter, the group has a nice package of ballot access in a number of states. Richard Winger too notes the potential for the group’s ballot access use in the future.

Meanwhile Lessig responds to Lumea on neutrality and AE, something which seems pretty moot.

I expect Buddy Roemer will continue to try for the Reform Party nomination and he will continue to be a non-factor.  I’d keep an eye instead on Gary Johnson.

Why did AE fail?  First it is hard to build a movement around ballot access rather than a candidate.  Second, despite what partisans say on both sides, Obama and Romney are close enough to the center that there is not really room for a radically different candidate in the middle.

And then there was the bad press from the group’s democracy deficit, which was a self-inflicted wound.

Ballot access for third party candidates in this country is way too hard, and AE had a good idea to get around it.  But its execution did not work, especially how it tried to present itself as a publicly-driven force but a core group kept tight control of its rules and expected substantive outcomes.

Share
Posted in ballot access, third parties | Comments Off

Waiting Dept.

When is Tom Friedman’s column running when he explains why Americans Elect was not the next big thing?

Weigel explains what went wrong.

Share
Posted in ballot access, third parties | Comments Off

Americans Elect, Lessig, Roemer and Lumea: Whistling Past the Graveyard Edition

The discussion continues, even if Americans Elect may not.

Share
Posted in ballot access, third parties | Comments Off

Tweet of the Day

“Tom Friedman said Americans Elect would be Amazon.com & an iPod wrapped up in the blogosphere. And now it’s Pets.com.”

Peter Hart, via The Guardian.

Share
Posted in ballot access, third parties | Comments Off

Americans Elect Admits Its Selection Process Has Failed; New Procedures Coming

The following press release arrived via email:

A Statement by Americans Elect CEO Kahlil Byrd

12:01 A.M., MAY 15, 2012 -  Over the past two years, Americans Elect has focused on achieving three clear goals:

·      Gaining nationwide ballot access for a third presidential ticket to compete in the 2012 race;
·      Holding the first ever nonpartisan secure national online primary at AmericansElect.org; and
·      Fielding a credible, balanced, unaffiliated ticket for the 2012 presidential race.

Through the efforts of thousands of staffers, volunteers, and leadership, Americans Elect has achieved every stated operational goal. Despite these efforts, as of today, no candidate has reached the national support threshold required to enter the “Americans Elect Online Convention” this June.  (Read a detailed summary of the AE process here and the full rules here.)

Because of this, under the rules that AE delegates ratified, the primary process would end today. There is, however, an almost universal desire among delegates, leadership and millions of Americans who have supported AE to see a credible candidate emerge from this process.

Every step of the way, AE has conferred with its community before making major decisions. We will do the same this week before determining next steps for the immediate future. AE will announce the results of these conversations on Thursday, May 17.

As always, we thank everyone who has participated in this effort and will honor the work, efforts and trust so many people have placed in Americans Elect.

###

Share
Posted in ballot access, primaries, third parties | Comments Off

Americans Elect Near Death?

See this Time piece and Buddy Roemer’s desperate tweet.

Share
Posted in ballot access, third parties | Comments Off

“Ralph Nader Loses Challenge to Fees in Pa. Ballot Case”

BLT: “The District of Columbia Court of Appeals has denied former presidential candidate Ralph Nader’s latest attempt to set aside a Pennsylvania court’s judgment against him related to his 2004 run for president.”

Share
Posted in ballot access, campaigns | Comments Off

“AE Speaks, Claims May 15 Ballot Now Canceled, Too”

AE Transparency explains. See also With Failures Rapidly Mounting, What Is Americans Elect’s End-Game?

Share
Posted in ballot access, third parties | Comments Off

“ACLU/SC Sues California Secretary of State for Excluding Minor Political Parties from November Presidential Election Ballot”

Press release: “Today, the ACLU of Southern California is filing suit against California Secretary of State Debra Bowen on behalf of the Justice Party and the Constitution Party of California, which seek to have their nominees for President and Vice President included on November’s presidential election ballot, and individual voters who support the groups. The case was filed in U.S. District Court for the Central District of California.”

View the complaint.

Share
Posted in ballot access | Comments Off

“How S.C. 2012 primaries imploded (+ survey); Court ruling on filing law dumped 1-in-5 candidates from ballot”

The State reports [corrected link].

Share
Posted in ballot access, primaries | Comments Off

“Americans Elect: They Built It, And Nobody Came”

David Karpf has this oped at TechPresident.

Share
Posted in alternative voting systems, ballot access, third parties | Comments Off

Bueller? Bueller? Bueller?

Politico on Americans Elect: Third-party candidate for POTUS: Anyone? Walker?

Share
Posted in ballot access, primaries, third parties | Comments Off

“Americans Elect scraps virtual caucus for lack of early candidate support”

AP reports.

Share
Posted in ballot access, third parties | Comments Off

“First-Round Voting Deadline Passes At Americans Elect; AECorp Has No Comment”

AEI Transparency reports.

Share
Posted in ballot access, third parties | Comments Off

Lessig Goes All in With Americans Elect as the “Last Best Chance” for Campaign Finance Reform

He makes his case atThe Atlantic Wire.

Earlier, Lessig and I had an exchange about the serious problems I have with Americans Elect’s transparency and its democracy deficit.

I have also discussed Lessig’s campaign finance reform ideas in detail in a forthcoming Harvard Law Review book review (which also reviews a book by Jack Abramoff).

 

Share
Posted in ballot access, campaign finance, third parties | Comments Off

“The Inevitable Future Presidency of David Walker”

Weigel.

Share
Posted in ballot access, third parties | Comments Off

Cert. Petitions Filed by Democrats and Libertarians in Renewed Challenge to Washington’s “Top Two” Primary

Richard Winger has the documents.

Share
Posted in ballot access, political parties, Supreme Court | Comments Off

“Americans Elect sheds staff, delays voting till May”

Politico reports.

Share
Posted in ballot access, third parties | Comments Off

Is the Fix in For Americans Elect Candidate David Walker?

See Jim Cook and AE Transparency.

Share
Posted in ballot access, third parties | Comments Off

Occupy Americans Elect? Easier Said than Done?

John Lumea explains.

Share
Posted in alternative voting systems, ballot access, third parties | Comments Off

“Circulator Ruling May Not Apply to Dems, GOP”

Adam Bonin: “With all due respect, I’m not quite sure that Monday’s Pennsylvania Supreme Court decision regarding out-of-district circulators means quite what commentators seem to think it does. In short, while the decision clearly eliminates that requirement as to independent and minor party candidates seeking ballot access, I am not sure that it offers any relief to candidates seeking to appear on the primary ballot for one of the major parties.”

Share
Posted in ballot access, petition signature gathering | Comments Off

“Americans Elect waiting for big name as they seek to break two-party grip”

The Guardian offers this report, with the subhead: “Group says their plan to take on America’s two-party system is on track – but a lack of engagement is hampering their cause.”

Share
Posted in ballot access, third parties | Comments Off

Quote of the Day

“Not ignoring. We just won the People’s Choice Award at South by Southwest and on the road doing a tech tour. Perhaps we can catch up at another time.”

–Americans Elect’s press secretary, responding to the Sacramento Bee‘s Dan Morain on AE’s flagging presidential campaign.
Share
Posted in ballot access, third parties | Comments Off

“Independent, Schmindependent: Forget the Rules and the Rhetoric, the Reality Is That Americans Elect Is All About the Duopoly”

John Lumea’s latest.

Share
Posted in ballot access, chicanery, third parties | Comments Off

“Montana Secretary of State Won’t Let Libertarians Choose a U.S. Senate Nominee”

Richard Winger blogs.

Share
Posted in ballot access, third parties | Comments Off

“Don’t let Americans Elect muddy the 2012 race; A third-party candidate could get enough votes in a key swing state in November to toss the presidency to the otherwise loser.”

Harold Myerson has written this column for the LA Times.

Share
Posted in ballot access, third parties | Comments Off

“Santorum Faces Ballot Problems in Pennsylvania”

Political Wire reports.

Share
Posted in ballot access, political parties, primaries | Comments Off

Read the Reply Brief in Case Challenging Top Two in 9th Circuit

Here it is.

Share
Posted in ballot access, political parties, primaries, third parties | Comments Off

“Confessions of an Americans Elect delegate”

Alex Pareene: “This, though, was penned back when they were expecting a Michael Bloomberg to sign up for their effort. Now they can’t even manage an Olympia Snowe. Primary voting begins in less than two months, and the only declared candidate who actually meets those qualifications is … Buddy Roemer. At the moment, no candidate, declared or drafted, is on pace to actually meet the number of clicked supporters (10,000 for establishment candidates, 50,000 for outsiders) necessary to qualify for the ballot, which will almost certainly necessitate major rules changes. Americans Elect, then, is a high-profile third-party ballot access campaign without a candidate.”

It is worth pointing out that if we had more reasonable ballot access rules for presidential candidates, the questionable Americans Elect effort would be unnecessary.

Share
Posted in ballot access, third parties | Comments Off

“Joe Lieberman could back third-party candidate”

Surprise, surprise.  He’s “intrigued” by Americans Elect.

Share
Posted in ballot access, third parties | Comments Off

“Formal Call for Reversal of Americans Elect Board Of Directors Decision #1, a Violation of Rules and Bylaws”

This will be interesting to watch.

More on Americans Elect and mischief coming from me on Monday.

Share
Posted in ballot access, third parties | Comments Off

“Jon Huntsman Dropped From RNC Event For ‘Third Party’ Call”

BuzzFeed reports.

Share
Posted in ballot access, third parties | Comments Off

“Texas Democrats, Republicans, Ask U.S. District Court to Alter 2012 Ballot Access in Texas “

Ballot Access News reports.

Share
Posted in ballot access | Comments Off

Given Maine’s Ballot Access Rules, Running for Sen. Snowe’s Seat Will Be No Easy Task

Bangor Daily News:

The deadline to get on the primary ballot for Republican and Democratic candidates is March 15.  Any interested candidate will need to get 2,000 certified signatures by that date (which means well above 2,000 total if you figure in the names that will be thrown out), or they won’t be on the ballot.

The logistical requirements of actually meeting that hurdle are very high.  This is not something that can be done by a political novice in two weeks – indeed it is a difficult task for established figures.

In the 2010 gubernatorial contest, both Democrats and Republicans were having a difficult time getting enough signatures, and most campaigns only managed to finish collecting them a few days before they were due.  That was with a year (sometimes more) lead time.  People now have two weeks.

Unless something changes – I have heard mention that the Maine legislature has the capability to push that date back, but my sources say there have been no conversations about that yet – that means that the only people that can pull it off are folks with already established political machines, or people with the money to instantly purchase the manpower to get it done.

This has implications for more than just the Senate race.  If Chellie Pingree or Mike Michaud (or both) decide to run for the Senate seat, that means that potential candidates to replace them in the House of Representatives would have to meet that requirement as well

Share
Posted in ballot access, primaries | Comments Off

A Snowe-Boren Americans Elect Ticket?

Jonathan Chiat ponders.

I’ll have more to say on Americans Elect soon.

Share
Posted in ballot access, third parties | Comments Off

“Huntsman Calls for Third Party”

Political Wire reports. Bat signal to Americans Elect?

MORE from the NYT on possible third party candidates.

Share
Posted in ballot access, third parties | Comments Off

Jon Huntsman Flirting with Americans Elect Bid?

Note the “duopoly” comment (via Ken Vogel).

Share
Posted in ballot access, third parties | Comments Off

“Netural” Americans Elect Promotes Potential Candidate David Walker Through Press Release

Americans Elect has an official policy of neutrality (rule 6.1) when it comes to which candidate should get the Americans Elect nomination.  Yet one day after Tom Friedman wrote a fawning New York Times column promoting David Walker as a potential presidential candidate (without mentioning Walker’s membership on the AE board), I received this press release:

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

BOARD MEMBER DAVID WALKER EMBOLDENS VOTERS TO FACE THE CRITICAL CHALLENGES OF OUR NATION
WASHINGTON, D.C., FEBRUARY 20, 2012 – Dave Walker knows the facts, the truth and the tough choice we face in connection with our nation’s poor finances and other key challenges. As the nation’s former chief auditor and head of the U.S. Government Accountability Office for almost 10 years, Walker has front-line experience in connection with the many challenges and partisan gridlock in Washington that literally threaten our nation’s and our families’ futures. Walker’s three presidential appointments from Reagan, Bush and Clinton, combined with his many years of private and non-profit leadership experience, and his engagement with Americans in all 50 states, led him to Americans Elect, where he now serves as a member of the Advisory Board.

Walker currently serves as Founder and CEO of the Comeback America Initiative, which engages the public and policymakers on fiscal issues and nonpartisan solutions that can achieve bipartisan support. Walker understands that Americans Elect’s online nominating process for president combined with its independence from the two major political parties has the ability to shock the current political system in a positive manner.

Walker is an author of three books, a national co-founder of No Labels, a member the Accounting Profession’s Hall of Fame, the Sons of the American Revolution, and the Trilateral Commission. His experience in these areas make him an important resource for Americans Elect moving forward.

“This nation has faced great challenges in the past, and it’s always risen to successfully address those challenges. It’s time to do so again.” said Walker. “Americans Elect is providing the American people with more choice and competition in connection with the nation’s two highest offices. It offers an opportunity to break the partisan gridlock and to bring to life the first three words of the U.S. Constitution – ‘We the people.’”

“Now more than ever, this country needs truth, leadership and sensible, nonpartisan solutions to the key challenges that we face. The Americans Elect process will give every registered voter – no matter their party or point on the political spectrum – a say in how best to change course and right our ship of state so that our future will be better than our past.”

###

Let’s Make History!

Americans Elect

Become a delegate now at AmericansElect.org

Share
Posted in ballot access, third parties | Comments Off

“Stephen Colbert passes Buddy Roemer in Americans Elect draft”

NoLa.com reports (via BAN).

Share
Posted in ballot access, third parties | Comments Off

Has Tom Friedman Given Up on Americans Elect?

Sure seems like a change of heart (h/t Ken Vogel).

Share
Posted in ballot access | Comments Off

“Americans Elect Invites Vote Buying & Selling, Rejects Voter Privacy!”

See here.

Share
Posted in ballot access | Comments Off

Quote of the Day

“Irony. They won’t disclose donors’ identities, but they will disclose voters’ identities”

–Pamela Smith, President of Verified Voting, commenting on the news that there is no secret ballot in the Americans Elect Internet nominations process.

Share
Posted in ballot access | Comments Off

Voting in Americans Elect Internet Primary Will Not Be Secret

I have been very critical of Americans Elect’s rules and procedures for conducting its nomination process, including its use of the Internet for voting.  William Kelleher, who is generally a supporter of Internet voting, wrote to Americans Elect to ask if they have a secret ballot for their Internet voting process.  Here is the response he received.

*Dr. Kelleher & Andrea,

Thank you for the security questions.  I hope my answers will be sufficient.

1. Each vote is tied to name. Necessary so we can audit the convention afterwards. This is not a secret vote (like the general election is).

2. Only our technology team has access to the server which is led by Josh Levine. Each round of voting will be followed up by an audit. Per our rules:

5.4       Independent Candidate Vote Integrity Compliance. The voting integrity audit shall be conducted by an independent auditor in accordance with standards published by the Technology Integrity Committee to be completed within 48 hours after any Candidate Votes, or such additional time as the Board may allow for good cause. The Board shall have the ability, on recommendation of the independent auditor, to declare any vote a nullity in the event of a material breach of voting security and to order a re-vote upon email notice to all Delegates.

Alice M. Skelton

Americans Elect

National Engagement Director

What remains unclear at this point is whether AE will mail paper receipts showing how people voted to AE voters, a move which can facilitate vote buying.

Share
Posted in ballot access, internet voting, voting technology | Comments Off

“Four Georgia Senators Introduce Bill to Require Petition Signers to Show Government Photo-ID”

Ballot Access News reports.

Share
Posted in ballot access, voter id | Comments Off

NCSL’s “The Canvass” Focuses on Ballot Access

Here.

Share
Posted in ballot access | Comments Off

“Newt Gingrich drops quest for Virginia ballot”

Josh Gerstein reports.  Maybe better to lose in the courts then get trounced in his own backyard?

Share
Posted in ballot access | Comments Off

Ninth Circuit Brief Filed in Top-Two Case

From the challengers: “Our Brief shows that California’s Top Two Primary Law violated the rights of Californians in two troubling ways.  First, it unconstitutionally violated the rights of minor-party candidates, by forcing them to falsely state on the ballot that they have ‘No Party Preference’.  Second, the Top Two Primary law disenfranchised all voters who cast write-in votes in the general election.”

While the issues are certainly distinguishable from those addressed in the recent top-two primary case involving Washington State recently decided by the Ninth Circuit, I find it very curious that the brief does not even cite this case, which certainly addresses issues of constitutional standards of review applicable to minor party constitutional challenges.

Share
Posted in ballot access, political parties, primaries | Comments Off

“Tennessee Ballot Access Law for New and Minor Parties Struck Down”

Ballot Access News reports on what could be a significant ruling for minor parties.

Share
Posted in ballot access | Comments Off