Was Chief Justice Roberts Most Unprincipled in Applying the Doctrine of Constitutional Avoidance in the Health Care Case, in NAMUDNO (the Voting Rights Act Case) or in Citizens United?

In my initial post on the health care decision, I stated “Once again, the Chief has manipulated the doctrine of constitutional avoidance to do what he wanted to do in a high profile, important case.” I hadn’t had a chance … Continue reading

Share

“The ‘CBO Canon’ and the Debate Over Tax Credits on Federally Operated Health Insurance Exchanges”

The following is a guest post from Abbe Gluck [cross-posted from Balkinization]: Abbe Gluck The latest fracas over health reform—the challenge to subsidies for the federal exchanges—offers a long-overdue opportunity to think about how particular features of modern lawmaking might … Continue reading

Share

Federal Court Declines to Enjoin Disavowed Florida Purge Under NVRA

In a decision released this morning, a federal court declined to issue a temporary restraining order in the DOJ’s NVRA challenge to Florida’s purported purge of noncitizens. Part of the reason was that the Florida Secretary of State Detzner apparently said … Continue reading

Share

“Either/Or: Professors Zephyr Rain Teachout and Akhil Reed Amar – Contradictions and Reconciliation”

Seth Barrett Tillman has posted this draft on SSRN.  Here is the abstract: The Foreign Emoluments Clauseis a constitutional backwater. So much so, that there is no substantial discussion of this clause in any federal adjudication (although the Office of … Continue reading

Share

Federal District Court Calls Out Supreme Court on Its Shoddy Statutory Interpretation of the VRA in the NAMUDNO Case

From today’s opinion in the Shelby County case, I was gratified (but somewhat surprised) to see the following passage in the district court’s discussion of NAMUDNO: On appeal, however, the Supreme Court reversed and remanded. In a decision that has … Continue reading

Share